Fanfare - January/February,
1992 - by Peter J. Rabinowitz
"Despite
the nationalist promise of its title, Amenca Sings! offers
neither folksy charm nor patriotic fervor. Rather, this disc consists
of live contemporary vocal works (1965-8O), apparently chosen by a
peer review system, mining a variety of accessible and familiar, but
not peculiarly American, idioms. There's nothing especially audacious
here, and nothing that will strike you with its distinctive compositional
voice; and I suspect that listeners will differ in their patience
for some of it. Depending on your taste, for instance, you may find
Gregoria Karides Suchy's mercurial Twelve Greek Maxims, which
leap from jagged severity to broad parody, either witty or arch; and
although I enjoyed the occasionally Messiaenic splash of Elizaheth
Varcoeshaiku settings, readers should be warned that Kyle
Gann, reviewing an earlier Northeastern release of this same performance,
called it "gutless expressionism"~"one of those angular,
academic works whose style and content are already too, too familiar"
(Fanfare 10:3). Still, whatever their reliance on well-tried
techniques, the five works are all solidly crafted; and the contrasts
between the from the sweet, piquantly harmonized lyricism of Diane
Thome's Three Psalms, through the sparser, more inward contrapuntal
musings of Joelle Wallach's often Brittenesque Mourning Madrigals,
to the ostentatious declamations of George Belden's partly electronic
Gilgamesh - makefor an attractive air.
As is often the case with such miscellanies, the quality of both performances
and recordings is uneven; and Capstone needs to pay more attention
to their presentation. I'm not complaining about the timing errors
on the jacket; nor is the pedestrian cover really an issue (although
it's hard to imagine anyone being motivated to explore the disc simply
by its visual impact). But texts are only provided for two of the
works; and the ho-hum notes - in nearly unreadably small type - simply
don't create a context for receptive listening. Capstone deserves
praise for its commitment to contemporary music - but if this music
is going to gain a hearing in an increasingly competitive world, it
needs to be introduced more aggressively."