American Record Guide - May/June, 2001 - by French
The superb liner notes
by both Alabaman Donald Ashwander (1929-94) and Matthew Davidson describe
the music best: hymns, sacred harp music, southern black music, and
popular music of the 30s and 40s
American poems using the simplest
of open harmonies and trusting the melody to carry the day. And does
Ashwander have an inventive voice of his own! And does Davidson have
style!
On the Highwire
is a mightily unsteady, wind-gusted, half-inebriated, swaggering strut.
The tempo in Forgotten Ballrooms is highly flexible but
not self-indulgent. Mobile Carnival and Business
in Town are perhaps the prime examples of Ashwanders constant
invention and cleverness. Waterloo Rag and Sunday
Night Manhattan, while offering refreshingly steady tempos for
a change, are incredibly infectious with that quality only a master
can create, the sense of improvisation despite the fact that its
all written down. Friday Night includes excellent contrary
motion, both literally and harmonically. We Danced
is it a waltz or a 2/4 statement? And in its reprise Peacock
Colors is hardly a repeat its yet more development
or variation, reconfirming Ashwanders inventive ability to create
the illusion of improvisation.
OK, I left a few out,
not because theyre lesser but to avoid being repetitive with
praise. The musics superb. The engineering is excellent. And
the performances have consummate style, though it takes Davidson a
bit too far into the album to serve up some shading. A bit more of
that plus variety in tone color would supply some relief from his
forward presence. A minor quibble. By the way, the titles (they all
come from the composers personal experiences) do get
reflected in the music. And never heard of Capstone? Try HYPERLINK
http://www.capstonerecords.org.
The
Mississippi Rag - October, 2001 - by David Reffkin
The many rags and rag-related
pieces written by Donald Ashwander are now appearing in folios and
recordings, largely thanks to Judith Ashwander Moore, the composer's
sister. When Ashwander died in 1994, his unreleased recording, "On
the Highwire" existed only on some cassettes that were circulated,
as the recording company had folded. Matthew Davidson, already a friend
and admirer of the composer, decided to rerecord the material (with
some additions and subtractions). The result is a set of pieces written
by an untrained composer who had a gift for melody and mood-setting
music, played by a performer whose musical instincts make the whole
project a success.
Just about every piece
is programmatic: an event or current circumstance found its way into
a musical composition. This is about as subjective a way to write
music as there is. I remember Donald Ashwander as a very sensitive
guy who was dynamic in normal conversation, observant and opinionated.
The "rags" are
not to be played (or heard) at all like classic rags. Most of the
pieces are a cross between sentimental/bluesy ballads and "songs
without words" and jaunty ragtime melodies. Playing them without
the appropriate rubatos and inflections would be totally against the
grain.
The better-known titles
on this CD are "Friday Night" (famous for its use in the
British dance production Elite Syncopations), "Sunday
Night, Manhattan," and "Astor Place Rag-Waltz" (one
of the few successful modern ragtime waltzes).
Some listeners might not
like the quirkier pieces, augmented by short vocals. For example,
for (Perdido Bay Moon Rag," Davidson includes the short song
lyric in the middle. Singing is not the strong point in these performances,
but it was exactly the kind of thing Ashwander did. One gets the impression
of a saloon pianist who is minding his own business at the piano and
suddenly erupts with an inspiration to improvise a song in the middle
of a tune. Along the same vein, The Brooklyn Start and Stop"
and "stop," that adds nothing to the piece unless the listener
cares to make up a dance. I doubt anyone will be doing this, though
it was done in live performance. By the way, there were no dance steps
for this!
The really best performances
for me are pieces like "Old Streets," where some good melodies
are hinged together and the pianist makes especially effective musical
sense of the sometimes roughly crafted score. "Business in Town"
sounds very much like an instrumental development of his song "Chili
Billy" (not on this CD). Another wonderful rendition is "Evanescence,"
a rag that reminds me of Billy Mayerl, Max Morath and Bill Bolcom
wrapped up in one piece.
The liner notes for this
recording should be held up as a model for similar projects. On seven
standard-size CD pages, we have Davidson's introduction, Ashwander's
original introduction and program notes for each piece, a postscript
and a biography - plenty of information in readable black print on
white paper (imagine that). And the eighth page shows a nice oval
photograph of Ashwander. This is a welcome relief from the work of
designers who think they're up for the Psychedelic Nanoprint Award.